Holds a Master’s degree in Linguistics, loves traveling and learning new languages. Fluent in Spanish, is learning French and Czech at the moment. Enjoys exploring national cuisines every time he visits new countries.
Claims that grilling is the art that he has been learning all his life long and is not planning to stop. Has been grilling for as long as he can remember. Author of numerous online and offline grilling masterclasses runs his own BBQ accessories shop.
Last updated: August 30, 2021
LilGrill is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here
When it comes to smokers, one of the best brands is Smoke Hollow. They have always been boasting of quality construction and competitive prices. However, they also offer a vast range of products. So, even if you’ve narrowed down your smoker choice to a Smoke Hollow product, it can still be hard to decide on the best one. Thankfully, we have done the hard work for you. The following is a guide to help you find the best Smoke Hollow Smoker so that your party will always have flavor.
Out of all the products we have reviewed (9, all in all), our Editor’s Choice is the Smoke Hollow 30164G. It is a medium-sized smoker with 1.7 cubic feet of space and three grates to store your food. It is highly durable, and the propane fuel and auto-starter makes it very easy to use. This is the smoker that will meet all your BBQ needs.
In addition to the Smoke Hollow 30164G, we have reviewed four other products that are sure to delight your senses. These products have in-depth reviews that list all their features. Furthermore, we have put together a buying guide that walks you through what to expect from a smoker. Finally, there is a frequently asked section that aims to answer any remaining queries. Together, your search for the best Smoke Hollow Smoker will soon be over.
Smoke Hollow 30164G. This is a great option if you want to feed both large parties and your small family gatherings as well.
With a cooking capacity of 1.7 cubic feet, it has more than enough space for all your smoking needs, while is also small enough not to take up your entire backyard.
Inside this smoker are three grates. They can be moved around, depending on how large the objects are inside your smoker.
The Smoke Hollow 30164G is powered by propane, which hooks up fairly easily. You can start the smoker with just one press of a button, which makes it really nice to use. As for heat, you can expect up to 10,000 BTUs, which gives you plenty of range, depending on what types of meat you’re trying to cook and smoke.
The burner itself is stainless steel. It is easy to clean and won’t rust, providing nice longevity. As for the outside, expect a solid, cool-touch handle. No matter how hot the inside of your smoker gets, you won’t have to worry about burning your hand.
Smoke Hollow 30164G is that the temperature can fluctuate on a windy day. While the heat won’t go out completely, there have been reports of temperatures fluctuating up to 30 degrees from what was initially set.
This is a bit disappointing, given the quality construction. So, if you do want to use the Smoke Hollow 30164G on a windy day, try to place it in a protected area.
For those that prefer a propane smoker, the Smoke Hollow PS40B is the clear winner. With a whopping 15,400 BTUs, you can cook just about anything you want to perfection. Inside the Smoke Hollow PS40B are four grates, which adds to a lot more versatility. No matter how tall or short your food items, are, you can easily make space in this quality smoker.
As for the construction, the Smoke Hollow PS40B won’t disappoint. It has a nice, cool-touch handle, so you never have to worry about burning yourself. The four legs are also adjustable so you can increase or decrease the height. This extra feature is one of the ways Smoke Hollow continues to be innovative as a company.
Other features include an adjustable air damper so you can control the smoke and moisture content. Smoking is a bit of an art form, so the more control you have, the better the end result will be.
Assembly of the Smoke Hollow PS40B is fairly easy, although the instructions aren’t as clear as you would hope. It might take a bit of intuition, but overall most people were able to figure things out.
The biggest drawback with the Smoke Hollow PS40B seems to come with the temperature. As is the case with most smokers, the temperature can fluctuate a bit. It’s best to purchase your own thermometer, especially when you’re starting out, to get a second opinion of the internal temperature. This way you can still make your favorite recipes to your exact requirements.
Our pick for the best value Smoker Hollow Smoker is also Amazon’s top pick for a Smoke Hollow product. With a double recommendation, this is a product you’ll definitely want to consider.
The Smoke Hollow 26142E is a bit on the smaller size, having 1.3 cubic feet cooking capacity. It also only has two grates, although they can be arranged according to your needs. However, this smoker is still a nice size and will meet your needs. The smaller footprint also makes it easier to store and move around, so its portability is a nice feature.
As for the heat source, the Smoke Hollow 26142E uses electric heat. This is such a nice feature. Propane is fine, but anyone who has run out of fuel mid-cook knows how frustrating it can be. With electric, simply plug in your smoker and never worry about not having your cooking needs met. You will need to place the smoker near an outside electric outlet, but this should be simple nowadays.
Included with your purchase of the Smoke Hollow 26142E is a porcelain-coated water pan as well as a chip tray. These accessories are essential to providing accurate and consistent temperatures and cooking.
The outside of the Smoke Hollow 26142E is nicely designed. It offers the standard matte black finish that most Smoke Hollow products have. The handle is cool to the touch and there are side handles for when you need to move the smoker.
Perhaps you want to purchase a smoker, but your BBQ is showing signs of needing to be replaced. However, you only have the budget for one new appliance. The Smoke Hollow 3500 is the perfect solution. It is an impressive BBQ that also has a smoker attached to the side of it. This beast will create a feast that will have all your neighbors quickly knocking on your door.
The Smoke Hollow 3500 is a gas and charcoal grill and smoker. It has a cooking area of 860 square inches. The main part acts as a BBQ with a dual lid so you can better control the different foods you are simultaneously cooking.
One the side you will find a covered smoker. The smoker itself is small, so this is not the best option if you want to smoker vast amounts of meat. However, it is large enough to smoke a roast or a brisket.
The BBQ part of the Smoke Hollow 3500 has three burners and the capacity for 30,000 BTUs. The smoker, meanwhile, has a capacity of 9,300 BTUs. This range allows for varied temperatures and cooking times.
For the smoker, you can use charcoal to increase the flavor. There is a temperature gauge for accurate cooking and cast-iron cooking grids. This machine is very easy to use. It takes a bit to set up, and the size means you want to find one spot for it and keep it there. However, there are four wheels so if you want to move it, it is portable.
Beginners, take note: the Smoke Hollow D4015B is the model for you. Sometimes, it can be hard to trust what is happening inside a smoker. Despite all the controls and temperature gauges, sometimes we need to see to believe. If this is the case with your, the Smoke Hollow D4015B is a must-have product. Its large glass door means you can keep careful watch over your precious meat.
Smokers work best if they are kept at an even temperature. Constantly opening the door and checking on your food items means cold air quickly comes inside. A glass door means you can see what is happening and also provides a nice focal piece for any BBQ.
The Smoke Hollow D4015B is quite large. It has a cooking capacity of 4.5 cubic feet, making it the largest product on our list. It also has four grates that are movable. No matter what you want to smoke, there is room for it, and more importantly, adequate air flow for consistent temperatures.
One of the best features of the Smoke Hollow D4015B is that it has a remote control. You can sit down, enjoy a beverage with your friends, and change any settings according to your recipe. Unfortunately, the smoker needs to connect to your smart phone via Bluetooth, and sometimes, this technology is lacking in consistency. However, if you find the controls aren’t working, you can simply go to the smoker itself and adjust the settings right on the machine.
What stands out?
Large, glass see-through door
Very large capacity
Includes four grates
What cons did we manage to find?
Bluetooth might not work consistently
Things to Consider
Ready to purchase a new Smoke Hollow smoker, but are still a little unsure. To help you understand which product is best for you, make sure you read our buying guide. All the answers you need are here.
Features to consider when choosing a Smoke Hollow smoker
There are many Smoke Hollow smokers to choose from: so many that it can become quite confusing. At the heart of all smokers, however, are key features you can use for easy comparison. Here are the features to understand so you can find the right one for your needs.
Wanting to be completely different, the Smoke Hollow 3500 uses propane and charcoal for grilling.
Propane and electric both have their pluses and minuses. Electric smokers are less expensive to run but you will need to place your smoker near an outlet or have a large extension cord running on the ground. Propane is therefore more convenient, but make sure you have a reserve cannister so that your smoking doesn’t become interrupted.
When it comes to smokers, you want to have enough cooking space for all your eating needs. There’s no point purchasing a smaller order if you know you’ll be entertaining all summer. Before you purchase a Smoke Hollow Smoker, think about what uses you will have for it. Then, purchase the right size.
On the smaller end, the Smoke Hollow 26142E offers 1.3 cubic feet of space. This is perfect for small batches or feeding immediate family. On the larger end, the Smoke Hollow D4015B has 4.5 cubic feet of space. This is the model you want if you have the whole neighborhood over, every weekend.
Just remember that with extra cooking space comes extra overall space. Think about where you will be placing your smoker and take careful measurements. Also remember to leave space around the smoker as even the most well-crafted devices can get quite warm on the outside.
Number of grates
Within a smoker you will find grates to rest your food. The number of grates, combined with the cooking space, will help you determine how much food production you can get. You can expect between two and four grates. This number usually corresponds to the overall size. One of the smaller models on our list, the Smoke Hollow 26142E, only has two grates, while the much larger model, the Smoke Hollow D4015B, has four grates.
The nice thing about grates is that they are movable, much like over racks. So, if you want to smoke a large roast, you can adjust accordingly so there is plenty of room and air flow.
When you think of smoking, you might typically think of a low temperature range. But why settle for just low temperatures when you can have a more powerful range? The Smoke Hollow 30164G offers a practical BTU maximum of 10,000 units. The Smoke Hollow 3500, on the other hand, offers 30,000 BTUs. However, this model also works as a BBQ, so it needs the extra heat power to be so versatile.
Instead of BTUs, you might see a smoker advertise its temperature range, instead. The Smoke Hollow 26142E has a temperature range of 175 to 325 degrees Fahrenheit, while the Smoke Hollow D4015B can go up to 290 degrees Fahrenheit.
Just where do you think you’ll be putting your new Smoke Hollow Smoker? The best place is outside, in a well-ventilated area. It can be near the house, but you don’t want it touching the wall as even the best smokers can give off some external heat.
You can expect your smoker to be a tall, rectangular shape, so keep in mind width and length, as well as height.
If you are going for a smoker and BBQ combo, like the Smoke Hollow 3500, expect a very large footprint.
While the basic construction of a smoker includes a large box with a heating element, there is so much more that they can offer. Some smokers will have a viewing window. This allows you to see your food in all its glory. A viewing window is especially perfect for beginners as it allows them to see what’s going on without constantly opening the door. Opening a smoker’s door should be kept to a minimum; otherwise, cold air can quickly come in, disrupting the consistent temperature that is needed for perfect smoking.
Most smokers should include a water pan and a chip tray. Water helps control the humidity, and a chop tray allows you to add wood chips to further season your meat.
What’s really nice about Smoke Hollow smokers is that they all come with cool-touch handles. Smokers can get quite hot, and you don’t want to worry about burning yourself. With cool-touch handles, no matter how hot the insides get, the handle will remain cool and easy to open.
Finally, as with all major investments, having the right warranty is paramount. All Smoke Hollow products come with a one-year warranty. If any issues arise within this period, be sure to contact customer support to deal with any problems.
Smoke Hollow is an amazing brand that offers premium products. You can trust their integrated thermometers. If you are worried, however, simply purchase a standalone thermometer and use it in conjunction to make sure everything is accurate. Then, if you still have concerns, be sure to contact their customer support to help you out.
Most smokers will have a tray that can be placed inside. You can then add your own wood chips. There are many types of wood chips that will emit different smokes and flavors. It’s best to try a few and experiment with flavors to see what you prefer.
Yes, all the Smoke Hollow products are made for the outdoors and are weather-resistant. However, to ensure longevity, it’s recommended to either store your smoker in a dry, cool place when not in use, or to purchase a cover to further protect it from the elements.
Ready to impress everyone at the next BBQ? It’s time to find the right Smoke Hollow smoker. Our Editor’s Choice is the Smoke Hollow 30164G. With 1.7 cubic feet cooking capacity, it is large enough for family dinners while compact enough to be portable. If you really want a propane smoker, try the Smoke Hollow PS40B. It is quite powerful and easy to use. Finally, if you are on a budget, consider the Smoke Hollow 26142E. With a smaller, 1.3 cubic feet of cooing capacity, it might not be able to create a meal for the whole neighborhood, but it will still produce wonderful, flavorful food. With the best Smoke Hollow smoker, you will be sure to enhance your culinary capabilities.