Camp Chef vs. Traeger: Which Pellet Grill to Choose?

Can't decide between Camp Chef and Traeger? We compared them for you.
By
reviewed
Reviewed by
Last updated: August 27, 2021
vs
Can't decide between Camp Chef and Traeger? We compared them for you.
LilGrill is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Today, pellet grills are in high demand, thanks to their ability to add that unique smoky flavor to foods. However, identifying the right brand or model to buy can be quite complicated. It’s even more complicated when you have to choose between Camp Chef and Traeger, two of the most popular brands on the market. Trust us; you can easily make the right choice with the right information at your fingertips.

Besides, Chef vs Traeger is a worthy match. Although Traeger is the pioneer of pellet grill, Camp Chef is fast catching up with some forward-thinking, fantastic advancements in the industry. This article will place both products side by side—Camp Chef vs Traeger—and dissect their best models.

Certainly, lack of the right information won’t get you anywhere in your quest to buy a reliable pellet grill. So, in this guide, we will provide you with every piece of information you need in your bid to find the right pellet grill. Let’s get right to it!

Brands comparison

Camp Chef

The Camp Chef brand is the brainchild of Ty Measom, who was both inspired and frustrated with the quality and sizes of outdoor cooking equipment available in the 80s into the 90s. In 1990, he began making outdoor cooking equipment with the goal of manufacturing powerful and portable products.

Although the Camp Chef started with cooking equipment such as cast iron pieces, grill box attachments, and griddles, pellet grills soon joined the mix. Over the past 30 years, the company’s product line of outdoor cooking equipment has expanded.

Camp Chef vs. Traeger: Which Pellet Grill to Choose?

This cooking equipment giant has made outdoor cooking very seamless. For instance, it offers you the chance to use the same cooking system to bake pizzas, grill burgers, smoke a brisket, amongst other foods—the benefits are endless. Better still, Camp Chef has a fleet of cooking equipment that allows interchangeable attachments.

Camp Chef cooking equipment include Pellet Grills, Propane Grills, Propane Smokers, Burner Stove, Griddle, Fire Pit, Oven, Hardwood Pellets, Disposable Grease Bucket Aluminum Liners, Smoke Tube, Seasoning, Propane Water Heaters, Cook Books, Carry Bags & Covers, Cast Iron Cookware & Bakeware, amongst others. The company has a bigger lineup of products compared to its competitor, Traeger.

Camp Chef offers impressive warranty opportunities, including repair or replacement of any defective product. The warranty is, however, voided if the damage is caused by misuse, alteration, overheating, or abuse. Camp Chef has a 30-day refund policy for unused cooking equipment, without shipping costs. Traeger also has a similar policy, but it’s valid for 45 days after purchase.

Traeger

As we hinted earlier, Traeger is responsible for the invention of the Original Wood-Fired Grill over 30 years ago. Based in Mt. Angel, Oregon, the brand has continued to be a leader in the industry over the years. The company has mastered and perfected the art of wood-fired cooking, fueling your hunger for the unmistakable wood-fired flavor.

Traeger has incorporated exciting pieces of technology into its pellet grills. For instance, it uses the HotRod to ignite the grills, while a fan helps to circulate smoke and heat for even and consistent cooking.

Camp Chef vs. Traeger: Which Pellet Grill to Choose?

Also, the brand uses a digital controller to maintain a precise temperature during cooking, so that you can do other things while your food grills. As if that wasn’t enough, the manufacturer equips its pellet grills with WiFIRE-enabled controllers designed to help you control your grill regardless of your location using the Traeger App.

Apart from Pellet Grills, Traeger also offers Wood Pellets, Apparels (Hats, Hoodies, T-shirts), Sauces, Rubs, and Grill Covers. The company’s limited warranty only covers defects in workmanship and material under normal maintenance. Like Camp Chef, the warranty also does not apply to damage caused by misuse, overheating, alteration, or abuse.

Camp Chef vs. Traeger: Comparing Popular Models

No doubt, it can be difficult to spot the differences and similarities between Camp Chef and Traeger comparable models unless they are placed side by side. Below, we will compare separate models of Camp Chef and Traeger Pellet Grills based on factors such as cooking area, hopper capacity, maximum temperature, dimensions, weight, overall performance, ease of use & cleaning, amongst others. Ride along with us!

Camp Chef Woodwind PG24CL vs. Traeger Timberline 850

Camp Chef Woodwind PG24CL Traeger Timberline 850
Total cooking area 800 sq. in 850 sq. in
Hopper capacity 22 lbs. 24 lbs.
Max. temperature 500 °F 500 °F
Wi-Fi Yes; Camp Chef Connect App Yes; Traeger smartphone app
Dimensions 49 x 43 x 30 in 51 x 46 x 28 in
Weight 156 lbs. 208 lbs.
Warranty 3-year limited 3-year limited
VIEW ON BBQGUYS VIEW ON TRAEGERGRILLS

Overall Performance

Why do buyers seek information about the brand and model of the pellet grill they’re buying? The reason is simple. They want an easy-to-use and high-quality grill that promises optimum performance.

It’s no surprise that the Camp Chef Woodwind PG24CL boasts everything you need from an ideal pellet grill to satisfy customers. If you desire that unique, tasty smoky flavor in your food, this pellet grill is a smart choice. The Traeger Timberline 850 also offers as much exciting performance with its many advanced technology-driven features.

Moreover,  the Camp Chef Woodwind PPG24CL is equipped with a PID and WiFi-enabled controller that helps to change the cooking temperature and set timers. As if that wasn’t enough, the controller also helps to provide you notifications when your food attains your set temperature. You can control all of these features from the palm of your hand thanks to the Camp Chef Connect App that connects to your smartphone.

The Traeger Timberline 850, on the other hand, does not lack this smart and convenient technology. It uses the Wifire® Technology to help you control your pellet grill anytime from anywhere. This model connects to the Traeger mobile app, helping you to adjust temperatures and monitor your foods.

Both the Camp Chef Woodwind PPG24CL and Traeger Timberline 850 are almost equal in performance thanks to their seamless operations. The two models guarantee many years of top performance and offer three years warranty in case of defects in material or workmanship.

Cooking Area

Camp Chef vs. Traeger: Which Pellet Grill to Choose?

The Camp Chef Woodwind PG24CL offers a cooking area of 800 square inches. This wide space allows you to grill plenty of foods that can serve you and your visitors. The Woodwind PG24CL’s cooking area is great for its price, and you’ll enjoy cooking your foods on it.

The Traeger Timberline 850, on the other hand, offers a bigger cooking area, measuring 850 square inches. This means you get to cook more foods on the Traeger Timberline 850 compared to the Camp Chef Woodwind PG24CL. The Timberline 850 is perfect for your outdoor family events.

If you’re choosing your preferred pellet grill based on the cooking area, the Traeger Timberline 850 is the winner here.

Temperature

Grilling heavily depends on high temperatures. A grill with low temperatures is no grill. We are not surprised that both the Camp Chef Woodwind PG24CL and the Traeger Timberline 850 have an impressive temperature range. The Woodwind PG24CL boasts a temperature range of 160º F – 500ºF, helping you to grill your meat to your satisfaction.

The case is not different from the Timberline 850 which offers a maximum temperature of 500°F. It helps your food to reach your preferred temperature level.

Ease Of Use

Both the Camp Chef Woodwind PG24CL and the Traeger Timberline 850 pellet grills offer great ease of use and convenience. While the Woodwind PG24CL boasts the PID controller to ensure consistent temperatures (+/-5°F) during cooking, the Timberline 850 features the D2 Timberline Controller to help you maintain a precise temperature for consistent cooking results.

The Woodwind PG24CL’s PID controller helps you regulate both temperature and smoke. You get to adjust the Smoke Number to increase or decrease your smoke output. Camp Chef even offers a full-color screen to make the process very easy. The D2 Timberline Controller, while helping you to regulate your cooking temperature, also offers the Super Smoke Mode that allows you to increase the flavor with only the press of a button.

Both pellet grill models are compatible with their mobile apps, helping you to operate your grill easily from anywhere.

Ease Of Cleaning

Cleaning the Camp Chef Woodwind PG24CL and the Traeger Timberline 850 pellet grills is quite easy. The Woodwind PG24CL comes with a patented Ash Kickin’ Cleanout that collects the ashes during cooking and disposes of them after cooking. With stainless construction, the Timberline 850 is also easy to clean after every use.

Camp Chef Woodwind PG36CL vs. Traeger Timberline 1300

Camp Chef Woodwind PG36CL Traeger Timberline 1300
Total cooking area 1236 sq. in 1300 sq. in
Hopper capacity 22 lbs. 24 lbs.
Max. temperature 500 °F 500 °F
Sear box Yes No
Wi-Fi Yes; Camp Chef Connect App Yes; Traeger smartphone app
Dimensions 49 x 63 x 30 in 51 x 58 x 28 in
Weight 177 lbs. 226 lbs.
Warranty 3-year limited 3-year limited
VIEW ON BBQGUYS VIEW ON TRAEGERGRILLS

Overall Performance

The Woodwind PG36CL is another impressive pellet grill created by Camp Chef. It’s the dream of every outdoorsman. This model combines exciting pieces of technology to deliver high-quality cooking equipment. Measuring 16 inches, the Woodwind PG36CL is bigger than the 24-inch Woodwind PG24CL. Just like its predecessor, the Woodwind PG36CL pellet grill features a PID and WiFi-enabled controller.

The Woodwind PG36CL’s controller is designed to help you change the cooking temperature as you deem necessary for the food on fire. You can equally use this controller to set timers and also receive notifications when your food reached the set temperature. You can use the PID controller by connecting it with the Camp Chef Connect App on your smartphone.

The Traeger Timberline 1300 is also a bit similar to the Timberline 850, but it offers more features and functions. When it comes to performance, it can hold its own against the Woodwind PG36CL. The Timberline 1300 offers an exciting grilling technology that promises unrivaled wood-fired flavor as well as durable performance.

The Timberline 1300 uses the Wifire® Technology to help you control your grill from anywhere anytime using the Traeger App that is downloadable on your smartphone. Like the Camp Chef Connect App, the Traeger App helps you to monitor your food, adjust temperatures, and browse more than 1600 recipes.

You will agree with us that top performance without durability is not good enough. The Woodwind PG36CL and Timberline 1300 deliver top performance for many years. In case of damage (not caused by you), both models come with three years warranty that will offer repair or replacement of your unit. You can buy both pellet grills and be confident that your investment is safe.

Cooking Area

Camp Chef vs. Traeger: Which Pellet Grill to Choose?

Outdoor grilling exercise is usually fun with friends and families. You want a pellet grill with a wide cooking area to grill enough food for everyone outside. A small cooking area won’t help you. The Camp Chef Woodwind PG36CL is designed to help you serve several people at a go. With a cooking area of 1236 square inches, the model offers you a wide grilling space for your foods.

The Traeger Timberline 1300, on the other hand, boasts a wider cooking area, measuring 1300 square inches. This model offers you the chance to grill plenty of foods at once, saving you some pellets.

If you’re a big fan of a wide cooking area, the Timberline 1300 is the better choice for you. Although the difference between both models is not too much, it is enough to make you choose the Timberline 1300.

Temperature

The beauty of grilling is getting to cook your foods to high temperatures. An ideal grill cooks to at least 400°F. It can even get better and reach up to 500°F to give you the luxury of cooking at any temperature you fancy. The Camp Chef Woodwind PG36CL cooks at a maximum temperature of 500°F.

The Traeger Timberline 1300 also boasts the same maximum temperature. Thanks to this model’s fully insulated construction, it ensures efficient pellet usage and consistent temperatures regardless of weather conditions.

With both pellet grills, you can grill your foods beyond 450°F and enjoy the amazing smoky flavor.

Ease Of Use

You’ll agree with us that ease of use is a very important factor in choosing the right product, be it a smartphone or a piece of cooking equipment. Without the ease of use, you’ll hardly enjoy the value of your money. We don’t doubt that you don’t want this. Thankfully, both the Camp Chef Woodwind PG36CL and the Traeger Timberline 1300 offer impressive ease of use. But let’s see how their easy functions compare.

The Woodwind PG36CL features a built-in ignition that ensures easy lighting to start your cooking. Apart from that, it comes with a PID controller that connects with the Camp Chef Connect App to let you set timers and adjust the cooking temperature with your smartphone.

The Woodwind PG36CL also features the Smart Smoke Technology that allows you to adjust the Smoke Number (1-10). The higher the Smoke Number, the higher the smoke output. That means you can control the level of smoky flavor you get from your food.

By comparison, the Timberline 1300 boasts the D2 Timberline Controller that helps you maintain a certain temperature for consistent cooking results. This model also offers the Super Smoke Mode (similar to the Woodwind PG36CL’s Smart Smoke Technology) that allows you to add to the flavor with only the press of a button.

Lastly, the Timberline 1300 features a pellet sensor that can help you remotely monitor the levels of the pellet through the Traeger app. With this feature, you’ll never run out of pellets in the middle of a grilling session.

Ease Of Cleaning

There’s no need to develop a headache over cleaning both the Camp Chef Woodwind PG36CL and the Traeger Timberline 1300 because they’re designed to ensure ease of cleaning. The Woodwind PG36CL comes with an Ash-Cleanout System that collects ashes during cooking and easily disposes of them after cooking.

With stainless steel construction, the Timberline 1300 is quite easy to clean and maintain.

Camp Chef SmokePro DLX PG24B vs. Traeger Pro 575

Camp Chef SmokePro DLX PG24B Traeger Pro 575
Total cooking area 570 sq. in 575 sq. in
Hopper capacity 18 lbs. 18 lbs.
Max. temperature 500 °F 500 °F
Wi-Fi Yes; Camp Chef Connect App Yes; Traeger smartphone app
Dimensions 47 x 43 x 34 in 53 x 41 x 27 in
Weight 140 lbs. 124 lbs.
Warranty 3-year limited 3-year limited
VIEW ON BBQGUYS VIEW ON TRAEGERGRILLS

Overall Performance

When it comes to performance, the Camp Chef SmokePro DLX PG24B doesn’t disappoint. It combines several amazing features and functions to deliver the best foods. With this pellet grill, you don’t have to waste valuable time over a BBQ pit. This model comes with two meat probes that are designed to make cooking very easy for you.

Furthermore, the SmokePro DLX PG24B provides a digital temperature readout that eliminates the guesswork from the cooking process. With this feature, you can easily monitor your cooking temperature. Thanks to this pellet grill’s Gen 2 controller, you can easily adjust the temperature to suit your preference. Also, the Smoke Control feature helps you to regulate the amount of smoke your food gets.

By comparison, the Traeger Pro 575 comes with a built-in meat probe that lets you monitor the internal temperature of your food without the need to lift the lid. This model boasts all-terrain, rugged wheels, making it the ideal backyard cooking equipment. On top of that, the Pro 575 features porcelain-coated grill grates that prevent your food from sticking.

Also, the Pro 575 boasts an enhanced controller that utilizes the WiFIRE® technology. This technology helps you to adjust as well as monitor your grill temperature from anywhere anytime. Unlike the SmokePro DLX PG24B that isn’t compatible with a mobile app, the Pro 575 connects with the Traeger app to make grilling easy and fun for you.

These pellet grills promise many years of top performance. Notwithstanding, both models offer a limited warranty of three years in case of defects in material and workmanship. Both manufacturers—Camp Chef and Traeger—won’t redeem the warranty if the damage to the grill is caused by you. But if you qualify for the warranty, the manufacturer will offer you a repair or replacement. This makes you confident you’re not throwing your money away.

Cooking Area

Camp Chef vs. Traeger: Which Pellet Grill to Choose?

When searching for the ideal pellet grill, the buyer is usually concerned about the cooking area. The reason for such concern is not farfetched—the cooking area determines the quantity of food you can cook on your grill. The higher the cooking area, the higher the carrying capacity of the grill.

While some buyers prefer a high cooking area, others prefer a low cooking area depending on their preference. Let’s look at how much the cooking areas of the Camp Chef SmokePro DLX PG24B and the Traeger Pro 575 measure.

The SmokePro DLX PG24B offers a cooking area of 570 square inches. Although this is far from the widest cooking area, you still get the space to cook enough food for your family. The Pro 575 is a bit ahead of the SmokePro DLX PG24B in this aspect. It has a cooking area of 575 square inches.

The Pro 575 has a higher cooking area here although not by a wide margin. Regardless, you’ll have to make a choice based on your preference.

Temperature

Without the right temperature, there’s no grilling. Specifically, the ideal grill should reach more than 400°F. The Camp Chef SmokePro DLX PG24B and the Traeger Pro 575 boast the same maximum temperature of 500°F.

The SmokePro DLX PG24B offers a temperature range of 160º F – 500ºF, giving you the chance to grill at your desired temperature level. As we mentioned before, the Pro 575 also can cook food up to 500°F. There’s almost nothing to separate the two models in terms of temperature.

Ease Of Use

When it comes to ease of use, both the Camp Chef SmokePro DLX PG24B and the Traeger Pro 575 are impressive.

The SmokePRO DLX features an electronic auto-start ignition that ensures you start cooking without hassle. On top of that, this model features an advanced digital temperature chip that provides a more steady temperature and smoke. This temperature chip essentially eliminates large temperature swings and ensures a more consistent temperature during cooking.

On the other hand, the Pro 575 uses the WiFIRE® technology to connect to your smartphone, giving you easier control of your grill. With this connectivity, you can adjust and monitor your grill from anywhere. Not only that, but this model also boasts a new technology—D2® drivetrain—that allows the grill to start quicker and heat up faster.

Although both models are great in terms of ease of use, the Traeger Pro 575 edges it for us. It combines several cool features—especially the WiFi connectivity—to deliver top functions.

Ease Of Cleaning

The Camp Chef SmokePro DLX PG24B has the ease of cleaning in mind with the inclusion of the Ash Cleanout system that collects ashes and easily disposes of them after cooking. The Traeger Pro 575, on the other hand, features porcelain-coated grill grates that ensure food doesn’t stick, making clean-up a breeze.

Final Thoughts

Camp Chef vs. Traeger: Which Pellet Grill to Choose?

When it comes to a pellet grill, the top two brands are Camp Chef and Traeger. As we have established in this article, both brands are responsible for exciting and impressive pellet grills. After pitting them against each other—Camp Chef vs. Traeger—we realized there are few similarities and differences between them.

While they both allow a maximum temperature of 500°F during cooking, they differ in terms of cooking area. Traeger typically has a higher cooking area compared to Camp Chef.

Although all the models in this article are impressive, we liked the Camp Chef Woodwind PG36CL the most. Despite having a lower cooking area compared to its nearest challenger—Traeger Timberline 1300—the Woodwind PG36CL makes up for the deficit in performance. It offers great value despite the much lower price. Ultimately, you will have to choose the right grill based on performance and your preference

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *