10 Convenient Mail Order Steaks – Get Favorite Meats at Your Doorstep

With this article, you will learn more about the best mail order steak companies - where they deliver, sales, gifts and how to choose the one that will provide perfect cuts
By
reviewed
Reviewed by
Last updatedLast updated: August 06, 2021
LilGrill is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

A perfectly cooked steak is some people’s idea of heaven but you can’t always find the best cuts at your local grocery store. Rather than settling for inferior meat, choosing the best mail order steaks is something to consider. Several amazing companies deliver their quality products right to your door.

When choosing the mail order steak options for our reviews, we looked for certain features to ensure you’re getting the highest quality possible. First, the steaks needed to come from areas that are known for quality beef. We also checked for free shipping options, gift cards or boxes to send to your loved ones for those special holidays or events, and special discounts to help you save money. For more information on the best mail order steaks, check out our detailed reviews and buying guide below.

Top 10 Mail Order Steaks Review 2021

1.

Mr. SteakEditor’s Choice

Features
  • Origins: USDA Prime
  • Free shipping: $175+
  • Shipping policy: FedEx Ground, FedEx 2-Day Air, FedEx 1-Day Air
  • Gift cards: $$50-250

More features: 15% off the first order, 20% off grill master box

Mr. Steak is a family-owned company that features only the highest quality USDA Prime beef and a few Japanese Wagyu steak options. They have several cuts available, including Filet Mignon, boneless and bone-in ribeyes, T-bones, and even a huge porterhouse. They also sell some delicious pre-made burgers and brats, plus they have several boxes available full of carefully selected options.

This company is perfect for those who love their steaks but don’t live near a decent steakhouse. It’s also great for those who prefer to do their grilling at home, especially since you don’t need a subscription for the service.

What stands out?

  • We loved the amazing options available from Mr. Steak. They have several different USDA Prime cuts, as well as some Wagyu options, burgers, and even a delicious brat. All of their selections are shipped in biodegradable containers, plus they donate a meal to a hungry family for every placed order.

What cons did we manage to find?

  • The free shipping on orders over $175 is only a limited-time offer, so eventually, those savings will disappear and you’ll be paying full price for your shipping. This may not deter you from purchasing more delicious cuts, though, especially since the meat itself is all reasonably priced for the quality you’re getting.
2.

Snake River FarmsGreat Gift Boxes

Features
  • Origins: American Wagyu, USDA Prime
  • Free shipping: none
  • Shipping policy: FedEx Ground, FedEx 2-Day Air, FedEx 1-Day Air
  • Gift cards: $$25-5,000

More features: gift pack options from $101 to $301+, 15% discount on first order

Snake River Farms monitors the entire history of every head of cattle to ensure only the highest quality of meat is produced. They sell various cuts of premium American Wagyu and USDA Prime beef, all of which are wet-aged to ensure tender, juicy meat. As well as steaks, you can get burgers, roasts, hot dogs, and even some delicious Kurobuta pork options.

This steak delivery service is best for those who like to mix it up a bit for their meals rather than sticking to one or two types. Snake River Farms also has several pre-selected bundles available, as well as a variety of gift boxes for the meat lovers on your list.

What stands out?

  • Though they have some amazing meat options available, we loved that Snake River Farms has 17 different gift boxes to choose from, with varying price options to choose from. Their Provision Packs also give you a ton of meat at a lower cost than if you bought one at a time.

What cons did we manage to find?

  • Though this company has a simple ordering process, it doesn’t offer worldwide shipping. This means that only those in the United States can enjoy those delicious steaks. Anyone outside of this country will need to get their meat elsewhere.

3.

DebraggaBest Naturally Raised Beef Steaks

Features
  • Origins: USDA Prime, American Wagyu
  • Free shipping: none
  • Shipping policy: FedEx Ground, FedEx Standard Overnight, FedEx Standard Express
  • Gift cards: $$10-9,999

More features: 24-hour order processing, weekly specials discount

Rather than sticking to one type of meat, DeBragga offers a variety of naturally-raised, Wagyu, grain- or grass-fed, Angus, and Prime beef options, so you can choose the perfect cut to match your specific tastes. As well as the amazing beef cuts, you can also purchase Rocky Mountain lamb, pork, poultry, or venison.

This company stands out because they offer much more than other brands, including charcuterie options, smoked meats, spices, sauces, and many other kitchen or grilling essentials. This allows you to order everything you need all from the same place at once for added convenience.

Why did it make our list?

  • One of our favorite things about DeBragga is that they have weekly specials, offering a variety of options at a discount price. This lets you purchase more of your favorites or try something new. It isn’t all steaks, either, so you can try some tasty sausage, pork, or chicken at a lower price.

What is not ideal about it?

  • DeBragga is one of the most expensive options when it comes to mail order steaks. This isn’t a surprise since they offer premium grade options but it still may put them out of the price range of anyone on a budget. They also only ship to homes within the United States, so no international ordering.

4.

Porter RoadBest Value

Features
  • Origins: KY, TN, and PA
  • Free shipping: $100+
  • Shipping policy: FedEx Ground Standard, FedEx Standard Express
  • Gift boxes: $$300-900 subscriptions

More features: $15 off first purchase, Butcher’s choice boxes

Porter Road has been in business for over a decade, providing its customers with quality dry-aged beef that is humanely raised from responsible sources. They have a huge beef selection, with several quality steak options, as well as roasts, ground beef, pre-made burgers, and even a taco blend. They also ship pork, lamb, and chicken, with or without a subscription.

This brand offers high-quality items without the pricy butcher-shop costs. This makes Porter Road a great option for anyone who wants to enjoy fantastic steaks for a fraction of the cost. They also have a few reasonably-priced gift boxes available to share with friends and family.

What are our favorite features?

  • For anyone looking to buy quality meat without the high prices, Porter Road is one of the cheapest mail order steak companies we’ve found. Their prices are shockingly low, which may lead to equally low expectations, but their steaks and other meat options will please even the most refined palate.

What could be better?

  • Unlike some of the other mail order companies, we found Porter Road to be a bit limited in their selections. Though they offer a great deal of beef, chicken, pork, and lamb options, they don’t offer any specialty items or seafood, which forces you to get those from a different supplier.
5.

Holy Grail Steak Co.Best Kobe Beef

Features
  • Origins: Kobe beef, American Wagyu, USDA Prime
  • Free shipping: $199+
  • Shipping policy: FedEx Ground Standard, FedEx 1-Day Air
  • Gift cards: $$100-500

More features: $$219-379 gift packs

Holy Grail Steak Co. calls themselves a “one-stop steak nirvana”, delivering amazing steaks and other meats right to your door. Every cut is carefully sourced and hand-cut to ensure the highest quality possible. They have a wide variety of delicious steaks to choose from, so you can get exactly what you’re looking for.

This brand is best for those with more of a refined pallet that are looking for the highest quality of meat and don’t mind spending a bit more to get those perfect cuts. Holy Grail is also for anyone looking for unique items they won’t find anywhere else, like Italian Black Truffles in Olive Oil.

Why is it special?

  • We loved that Holy Grail has an amazing selection of beef options to choose from. This includes Japanese, American, and Australian Wagyu, as well as dry-aged steaks, Upper Prime Black Angus, carrot-finished beef, and even some burgers, Kurobuta pork, and Sonoma County lamb. With such variety, you can try a new option every day.

What are the flaws?

  • Though Holy Grail has steaks and other meat options that are some of the highest-quality available, they do come at an extremely high price when compared with other companies. This doesn’t mean they aren’t worth it, though you may want to take extra-special care of the cuts you choose.
6.

Crowd CowBest Grass-Fed Beef Steaks

Features
  • Origins: American and Japanese Wagyu
  • Free shipping: $99+
  • Shipping policy: FedEx Ground Standard, FedEx Standard Express
  • Gift cards: $$25-250

More features: 15% off the first order, $$42.75-141.55 gift boxes

Crowd Cow is located in Seattle, WA. They visit every ranch they source from to ensure only sustainable and ethical practices are used. You can choose grass-fed, pasture-raised, or either Japanese or domestic Wagyu beef for the perfect steak. They also sell chicken, pork, seafood, lamb, and so much more for you to choose from.

This is the best mail order steak brand for those who plan to buy a lot of steak. Crowd Cow offers memberships, which reduces the price of each order by 5%, so you can have your favorite cuts sent automatically or adjust them as needed at any time.

What are its best features?

  • Crowd Cow has the widest selection of any mail order steak company we’ve found. As well as various steak and other beef options, they sell chicken, seafood, and game meat, as well as some plant-based proteins for non-meat eaters. They even offer sides and desserts for a whole meal in one delivery.

What could be improved?

  • Though Crowd Cow has a huge selection of steaks and other meat options, we didn’t like that their free shipping on orders over $99 was only for members. Free shipping for everyone would be more of an incentive to buy from them, especially when you consider the price of cuts they have available.
7.

Allen BrothersGreat Gift Options

Features
  • Origins: American and Japanese Wagyu
  • Free shipping: $179+ for Wagyu burgers, $299+ for Angus filets
  • Shipping policy: UPS Freight Less-than-Truckload
  • Gift cards: $$50-1,000

More features: recyclable packing, gift cards

Allen Brothers has been in business for almost 130 years, so it’s no wonder they are one of the top mail order steak companies around. They offer varying types of steak, including USDA Prime, Wagyu, Dry or Wet aged, and even all-natural or grass-fed options. As well as their delicious steak options, you can order roasts, burgers, gourmet hot dogs, pork, veal, lamb, and so much more.

Allen Brothers focuses mainly on USDA Prime beef, so anyone who prefers this premier grade will likely want to order from this company over a few of the others. They also hand-pick all of their meat, which makes them a favorite among steakhouses and chefs.

What makes it stand out?

  • Our favorite feature that this mail order steak company has to offer is the Steak of the Month subscription, which sends specific steaks out each month for their customers to try. There are varying sizes available to feed one or two people or a whole family as needed.

Which disadvantages must you keep in mind?

  • Though Allen Brothers Steaks offer several different types of beef, from USDA Prime to AB Angus to Japanese Wagyu, they only have a few cuts to pick from. These include filet mignon, strip, ribeye, or porterhouse options. Anyone looking for other cuts will have to shop elsewhere.
8.

Omaha SteaksBest Grain-Fed Beef

Features
  • Origins: grain-fed beef
  • Free shipping: $169+
  • Shipping policy: Standard, Express (2-3 bd), Rush (1-2 bd), Saturday Rush (1-2 d)
  • Gift cards: $$5-500

More features: gift cards with customized signs, monthly special discounts

Omaha Steaks has been in business for over 100 years, starting with a butcher shop before expanding to more stores and online ordering. They have a huge selection of steaks at reasonable prices, plus they have a variety of meats other than beef for you to choose from. They even have appetizers, sides, desserts, and wine, making them a one-stop shop for every meal.

This company is one of the few that ships outside of the United States, so those in Canada, Puerto Rico, or the U.S. Virgin Islands can also enjoy the delicious products Omaha Steaks has for sale.

What are our favorite features?

  • Omaha Steaks has a larger selection of steak cuts available than almost any other mail order steak company we’ve looked into. They also have a huge selection of other items, including roasts, ham, veal, bacon, seafood, and beef jerky. They even have seasonings, rubs, sauces, and wines that match with anything you’re grilling.

What could be better?

  • Unlike many of the other mail order steak companies, Omaha Steaks doesn’t use eco-friendly packaging to mail their products. They use Styrofoam, which is not biodegradable or recyclable and isn’t safe for our planet. Despite the high quality of their steaks, this may have some customers looking elsewhere.
9.

Fossil FarmsBest Exotic Steaks

Features
  • Origins: Japanese and Kobe Wagyu, Angus
  • Free shipping: none
  • Shipping policy: UPS NJ
  • Gift cards: none

More features: $180+ minimal order rate

This company has four different types to offer when it comes to its steaks. You can choose Angus, Riedmontese, Japanese Wagyu, or domestic Wagyu, giving you the perfect cut to suit your taste. Depending on which one you choose, there are specific cuts to pick from.

Fossil Farms also has a variety of other specialty meat options available, making them a great choice for those who want to try some exotic meats. Many of their options are products that can’t be found through other mail order meat companies, putting Fossil Farms on top in this area of sales.

Why did it make our list?

  • We loved that Fossil Farms offers unique products that other companies don’t offer, including alligator, antelope, emu, ostrich, wild boar, yak, and kangaroo meat, just to name a few. All of the meat they sell is sustainably sourced from independently-owned farms and ranches that use no antibiotics, steroids, or hormones.

What is not ideal about it?

  • Fossil Farms has delivery from Monday to Friday, though they don’t offer Saturday deliveries. This means you may be waiting an extra few days for your steaks and other tasty products. Their meats are also a bit pricey, though the high quality may make this worth the extra cost, especially for those exotic items.
10.

Chicago Steak CompanyExcellent Boxes Subscription

Features
  • Origins: USDA Prime
  • Free shipping: $119+
  • Shipping policy: UPS & FedEx Standard, Express, Standard Overnight
  • Gift cards: $$25-500

More features: steak annual gift plan

The Chicago Steak company specializes in hand-cut USDA Prime beef from the Mid-West, ensuring quality meat in every order. You can choose wet or dry-aged Prime, as well as Premium Angus Beef or American Wagyu, all of which have different cuts to choose from. There are also burgers, seafood, side dishes, and desserts available to round out your meals perfectly.

This mail order steak company has a variety of gift boxes available for the men and women in your life. As well as single boxes, there are also subscriptions available for 6 or 12 months, making this brand best for those who want to share their love of steak with others.

Why did it make our list?

  • We loved the amazing variety of delicious steaks offered by this company. They have almost every cut imaginable, in a few different grades, so you get exactly what you’re looking for. They also have specials and deals, as well as free shipping on orders over $119, which helps save money for more tasty steaks.

What is not ideal about it?

  • Both the Wet and Dry-Aged products are aged for 4-6 weeks, which we found to be a bit vague since they don’t list an actual aging time for any of their steaks. Their porterhouse is also somewhat thinner than a usual porterhouse but still carries the high price tag.

Things to Consider

If you`ve never bought steaks online before, you may be a bit wary of what you`ll be getting in the mail. To help you make the right decisions in this area, our detailed buying guide can help you figure out what to look for in a mail order steak company.

Is it safe to order steaks online?

Yes, it is safe to order steaks online, provided the company you’re buying from is a trusted supplier who handles their food properly and ships their items frozen in a timely fashion.

For example, Chicago Steak Company puts a lot of effort in explaining the safety standards of their meats so you will always receive the best cut:

How to pick the best mail order steaks

If you’re buying steaks online for the first time, you may not be sure of what to look for. The following sections can help.

Prices

Quality steaks can be expensive, depending on the type of beef and cut you`ve chosen. The better the meat, the more you’ll pay. Of course, there are some cheaper companies, like Porter Road, plus many of the companies in our reviews have sales and deals, helping you save a bit of money without sacrificing quality.

Free shipping option

Many companies offer free shipping if you spend a certain amount. Crowd Cow is one of these, giving you free shipping on orders over $99, so the more you buy, the more you save.

Packing

All of the companies in our reviews send their meat out frozen in vacuum-sealed packages to ensure freshness, though the outer packaging may vary. Many brands, like Mr. Steak, pack their products in biodegradable containers, which are much safer for our planet.

Meat quality

The quality of meat is the most important feature to consider. Higher quality types, like USDA Prime, Black Angus, or Japanese Wagyu, are tender and delicious, but also cost a lot more than some other types of meat. The trade-off is amazing flavor, which steak aficionados will prefer.

Choice

10 Convenient Mail Order Steaks - Get Favorite Meats at Your Doorstep

All of the mail order steak companies try to offer a great variety of cuts to fill in the needs of even the pickiest customers

Not everyone chooses the same cuts when they order steaks, which is why having a great selection is a must. Most mail order steak companies offer several different cuts, as well as burgers, hot dogs, roasts, and much more. They may also offer seafood, venison, chicken, and other meat options, as well as sides, desserts, and in the case of Omaha Steaks, wine.

Guarantees

Some brands back their meat with guarantees that ensure freshness or satisfaction. This tells you that the company stands by their meat and practices, believing they are selling the highest quality to their customers. Though they may not offer returns, many of them will work with you to replace or refund the products that don`t meet your expectations.

Gift options

Gift options allow you to send the steak lovers on your list some tasty selections. All of the brands in our reviews have specialized gift boxes, gift cards, or subscriptions that you can order, or you can build your own box to send to family or friends.

FAQ

Yes, you can order steaks as gifts. When ordering, you put in the receiver’s address instead of yours to ensure it is sent to the right place. Most companies even have special gift boxes for you to choose from.

Yes, there are halal options for mail order steak delivery, though none of the companies we’ve discussed in this review follow the procedures needed for this designation. If you`re looking for this option, BOXED HALAL is a great mail order company to check out.

Our Verdict

As you can see from our reviews, there are several great mail order steak companies, though we have a few favorites we`d recommend.

Our top choice is Mr. Steak, which specializes in USDA Prime beef and has several amazing cuts to choose from. You can select your cuts or purchase one of their pre-made boxes, all of which are shipped in biodegradable containers. They also donate a meal every time an order is placed.

Snake River Farms sells American Wagyu or USDA Prime, monitoring the entire history of the cattle to ensure the highest quality possible. Their meat is wet-aged for tender, juicy cuts and they have 17 gift boxes available.

For the budget-conscious, Porter Road offers a wide selection of dry-aged cuts at a reasonable price. As well as steaks, they also have pork, lamb, and poultry available to try out.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *