8 Best Turkey Fryers for a Thanksgiving Staple

In this guide, we thoroughly tested and compared different turkey fryer models and brands to determine which one is the most ideal for you.
By
reviewed
Reviewed by
Last updatedLast updated: September 30, 2021
LilGrill is reader-supported. We may earn a commission through products purchased using links on this page. Learn more about our process here

Turkey is one of the most popular poultry meats consumed across the United States. The bird is mainly cooked by a lot of people during the national thanksgiving holiday. According to the National Turkey Federation, Americans consume a whopping Trusted Source Thanksgiving with Alexander Hamilton: Stewed eels, 'promiscuous' seating You might envision a celebration that would look like our image of the quintessential American Thanksgiving — family and friends gathered around a table laden with roast turkey and all the fixings. That certainly would fit with a quote widely attributed to Hamilton: “No citizen of the U.S. shall refrain from turkey on Thanksgiving Day.” www.usatoday.com turkeys on the National Thanksgiving day alone!

The National Thanksgiving day is not only full of turkey meat, giving thanks, and family-get-together. The day is also full of Trusted Source Although a mighty delicious tradition, deep-frying a turkey on Thanksgiving can be risky. Every year deep-fryer fires are responsible for five deaths, 60 injuries, the destruction of 900 homes, and more than $15-million in property damage, according to the National Fire Protection Association. www.foxnews.com . From turkeys skyrocketing in the air to homes burning down due to a grease fire, many things can ruin your holiday meal. If you want to avoid these disasters, then it’s time to invest in the best turkey fryers around.

We have dug deep into the internet and tested multiple products to bring you our top picks for the best turkey deep fryers on the market today. Our review paid more attention to features such as size, capacity, ease of use, safety features, overall user experience, and much more. 

Top 8 Turkey Fryers Reviews 2021

Features
  • Material: aluminum
  • Size: not specified
  • Capacity: 30-quart
  • Output:38,000 BTU

More features: CSA-approved safety timer, sturdy metal stand, adjustable safety brackets

The first product on our list of the best air fryers for cooking a turkey is the Bass Pro Shops 30 Quart Propane Turkey Fryer. This model comes with all the bells and whistles, including a large cooking area, easy access lid, adjustable safety brackets, removable drip tray, heavy-duty construction, and much more. It has been designed by professional chefs who know what they need to cook great food at any event. With its high-quality build, durable design, and CSA-approved safety timer, this unit makes sure that your guests enjoy their meals without having to worry about anything going wrong.

If you are the kind of person who quickly forgets they are cooking something in the kitchen, then this model might be perfect for you. Its CSA-approved timer helps you keep track of your preparation time. The feature eliminates guesswork and ensures that your turkey doesn’t end up being overcooked. Not only does it eliminate guesswork, but it also features an auto-shut mechanism that prevents turkey fryer accidents.

What are our favorite features?

  • One of the best features that fascinated us about this cooker is its fair price. At under $70, this model offers excellent value for money. Its low price doesn't mean that this cooker lacks essential features everyone looks for in a turkey fryer. It has got everything needed to prepare a delicious fried bad and other fried or steamed foods. The Bass Pro Shops 30-Quart Propane Turkey Fryer also has plenty of room to handle a turkey that weighs up to 18lbs.

What could be better?

  • This model could be better if it had a bigger capacity. It is only suited for cooking small to medium-sized birds. If you have a bigger turkey, you might have to split it into several parts and cook each separately. Separate cooking is a waste of energy and time. Another thing that could have made this cooker better is a powerful burner. Its 38,000 BTU burner is slow in frying, steaming, or boiling food.
Features
  • Material: aluminum
  • Size: 35.5 x 36 inches
  • Capacity: 36-quart
  • Output: not specified

More features: CSA-certified design, has two small baskets with coated handles, deep-fry thermometer

The Bass Pro Shores 36-quart All-in-one Fryer Kit is among the best turkey fryers for home use. This kit includes a 36-quart stainless steel pot and two baskets for frying, steaming, and boiling. With its sturdy base and ergonomic handles, this model is built to last. It’s constructed using premium materials. The cooker’s premium materials make sure that it’ll remain firm over a long time. What’s more? This model comes with a front copper spigot and a lid for easy draining.

This model differs from the Bass Pro Shops 30-Quart type in that it has a capacity of 36 quarts. The model is, therefore, able to cook turkeys weighing up to 22 pounds. It is also equipped with a 15-inch-deep fry thermometer, unlike its smaller counterpart cooker, which has a 12 inch one. This model makes cooking different foods at the same time much easier as it is equipped with one large and two small baskets.

Why did it make our list?

  • One thing that impressed us most about this model was its immense size. It can fry, steam, and boil birds or any meat weighing up to 22lbs. The second thing that we found interesting about the 36-Quart cooker is that it can cook two different meals simultaneously. You could be boiling one food and at the same time steaming your vegetable. This feature saves you time and energy.

What is not ideal about it?

  • Although this model is big and relatively affordable, it cooks slower than its smaller counterpart. The two models have the same burner capacity of 38,000 BTU. It could be better if this cooker had a giant burner. Since the fryer has an immense volume, it makes more sense to have a more powerful burner equipped to match its size. The fryer also lacks a thermostat to control the temperature of the oil to avoid overheating. This missing feature could lead to accidents if you are not attentive in the kitchen.
Features
  • Material: aluminum
  • Size: not specified
  • Capacity: 36-quart
  • Output:54,000-BTU

More features: large capacity, more efficient burning, clip-on stainless-steel thermometer, lid with build-in hook, Smart Temperature Control technology

The LoCo Cookers 36 Qt. Turkey Fryer by LoCo Cookers is one of the best turkey fryers that are guaranteed to make your Thanksgiving feast horror-free. This unit boasts many great qualities, including high-quality construction, capacity, burner power, and durability. The cooker features a 54,000 BTU high-pressure burner that has an intelligent temperature control sensor. The sensor prevents overheating and makes the burner 30% more efficient in heating than traditional models. With all those things combined, it makes sense why we listed this air fryer among the top choices for cooks looking for the right tool to make their holiday meals memorable.

The 36-Quart cooker is best suited for you if you have one eye on features such as fast cooking time, efficiency, or colossal capacity and the other eye on your wallet. If you are also looking for a safe fryer, then this is the go-to cooker. It is fitted with safety and convenience features that make your cooking even more effortless. Some of these features include a twist and drain system, poultry stand, lift handle, and so forth.

Why did it make our list?

  • What's more interesting about this model is fitted with a powerful burner that is more efficient. The powerful burner makes sure you cook your stuff in just minutes. The burner also has a Smart Temperature Control that prevents overheating and accidents. Not only does the Temperature Control prevent overheating and accidents, but it also reduces the fuel consumption of the cooker. When the oil gets too hot, the feature reduces burner power hence reducing propane consumption.

What is not ideal about it?

  • While this model offers an excellent cooking experience, we found out that its frying basket is made of thin aluminum that can be easily dented. It could be better if the baskets were made up of a thicker material that is firm. The cooker also lacks a safety timer which makes it hard to know how much time you have been frying your bird. If you are not careful enough, your turkey could be burned.
4.

LoCo Cookers SureSpark Turkey FryerMost Powerful Turkey Fryer

Features
  • Material: aluminum
  • Size: not specified
  • Capacity: 30-quart
  • Output:54,000 BTU

More features: high-pressure burner, cooks quicker, SureSpark electronic ignition system, Twist & Drain system, stainless-steel thermometer

If you’re in search of a compact yet reliable air fryer, then look no further than the LoCo Cookers Sure Spark Turkey Fryer. It’s small enough to fit into tight spaces and still handle medium-sized foods and birds. The cooker is much faster and cooks a more delicious bird 1/3 the time it takes to bake a turkey in a conventional oven.

What sets the LoCo Cookers Sure Spark Turkey Fryer model apart from other LoCo models is its ability to work indoors and outdoors because of its compact design. The model has less capacity and a powerful burner. It hence cooks faster and efficiently than its counterparts.

What stands out?

  • We were particularly pleased with the burner power of this cooker. It can get your oil ready for cooking in just under 30 minutes. Cooking with this gadget saves you time by up to 67% compared to ovens. Another thing that fascinated us about this model is its push-button electric ignition feature. You do not need a lighter to fire up this cooker. The quality makes it safer and less prone to fire accidents.

What cons did we manage to find?

  • Although the LoCo Sure Spark Turkey Fryer cooks faster and saves on fuel, the cooker has some shortcomings. According to our analysis, we think it could be better if it had a safety timer. The feature could have taken out the guesswork and the need to check your oil temperature from time to time as your turkey cooks. A safety timer also eliminates the risks of your bird overcooking or getting burned out.
Features
  • Material: stainless-steel
  • Size: not specified
  • Capacity: 30-quart
  • Output:38,000 BTU

More features: easy to clean, has a handy copper spigot, adjustable safety brackets, safety timer, endorsed by the National Wild Turkey Federation

The Bass Pro Shops Stainless 3-in-1 Combo Cooker is the most versatile turkey fryer in this listing. This multi-cooker can be used for both outdoor and indoor cooking. You can easily carry it to faraway places without much fuss. The cooker can fry any meat, boil any food, and steam all the types of vegetables and foods.

Due to its lightweight, this combo cooker is a handful for people who like camping or partying away from home. While camping or hiking far out in the forests, you won’t have to worry about fires or accidents as the cooker comes with a worry-free timer. For further safety, a 12-inch thermometer is also included to keep oil temperatures at acceptable levels.

What do we love it for?

  • One thing that stood out about this combo cooker is its lightweight design which makes it more portable. The fryer also comes with a heat shield. The shield ensures that heat is focused on your heater, reducing heat loss to the environment. Its marinade injector feature makes it easy and safer to add extra ingredients when preparing your tasty meals. The combo cooker also comes with adjustable safety brackets that hold the base of the steel stand and aluminum pot in place, preventing topple accidents.

What were we disappointed with?

  • What we think could be improved about this model is its timer. We found out that it has a 15 minutes' timer. The timer is fixed and cannot be adjusted. Most foods that need to be fried, boiled, and steamed need more than 15 minutes to be ready for human consumption. The other thing that can make this cooker better is incorporating a heavy-duty assembly free for added stability.
Features
  • Material: aluminum and stainless-steel
  • Size: 12.99 x 12.99 x 29.92 inches
  • Capacity: 30-quart
  • Output:50,000 BTU

More features: combo design, solid foundation, fully equipped, dual-riveted, and heat-resistant handles

The CreoleFeast TF K 3001 propane turkey fryer offers excellent performance at a reasonable price point. Its small size makes it ideal for use in smaller kitchens, apartments, and balconies. Don’t be fooled by its name; this cooker does not only cook turkeys and fish. It can cook any food imaginable in either oil or boiling water. It is that one set of a fryer that saves you all the hassles.

This cooker is excellent for you if you intend to be cooking small items and not heavy birds or fish. It can only hold up to 9.5 liters of oil and cook a birth with a weight not exceeding 18lbs. With such a small capacity and a powerful burner of 50,000 BTU, CreoleFeast TFK3001 can fry a basket full of turkeys or fish in just minutes.

What do we love it for?

  • What we like the most about this fryer is its adjustable air-controlled burner panel with a high-density wire mesh. It is explicitly designed to control oxygen and gas consumption for a clean blue hot flame. It also comes with lifting handles that make it easy to lift your fish or turkey once your food is ready. Its non-slip grip prevents your hands from heat and also ensures the smooth operation of the cooker.

What were we disappointed with?

  • According to our findings, we think that the CreoleFeast TF K 3001 propane turkey and fish fryer could be better if it could have been made of durable materials that do not get dented easily. A couple of customer turkey fryers reviews also suggest that the material can melt if heated for long. With such a powerful 50,000 BTU burner, it makes sense for the cooker to be made of solid and durable aluminum alloy.
7.

Chard TFP30A Aluminum Turkey Fryer PackBest Outdoor Fryer

Features
  • Material: aluminum, cast iron
  • Size: 14.2 x 14.2 x 17.3 inches
  • Capacity: 30-quart
  • Output:50,000 BTU

More features: adjustable regulator, safety timer and hose, 12-inch thermometer

The Chard TFP 30A aluminum turkey fryer pack is an affordable yet reliable outdoor fryer. This fryer pack comes with everything you need to make your outdoor cooking experience better. The 30-Quart cooker is perfect for frying turkeys up to 18 pounds, steaming vegetables, or cooking sauces savory enough to impress anyone.

The Fryer pack is made for outdoor use. The Chard TFP 30A is the fryer you need to take your cooking life outside the kitchen. You only have to pack this kit in your camping bag, find the right outdoor spot where you’ll enjoy never-ending views and fresh air. Finally, assemble it to cook endless creative dishes! The pack has everything you need for a seamless experience from start to finish, including a powerful 50,000 BTU burner for fast cooking, a thermometer, safety hanger, and poultry rack.

What do we love it for?

  • What we like the most about this outdoor cooker is its highly efficient burner that can be regulated. You can control the flame strength and intensity to avoid overheating and overcooking your food. Another feature we love about this gadget is its auto shut-off timer. The safety timer gives you peace of mind, eliminates the risks of fire accidents, and ensures food is cooked to perfection -- even when your cooker is unattended.

What were we disappointed with?

  • What could be improved about this cooker is making its base more stable. The fryer's stand is made up of weak aluminum legs which can bend easily. The manufacturers should use a sturdier and robust base stand to prevent the cooker from toppling when being handled. Toppling could lead to a disaster if the contents in the pot were too hot. Another thing that could be improved about this turkey fryer is its flimsy lid which can be dented easily.
Features
  • Material: metal and plastic
  • Size: 16.3 x 20.8 x 23.5 inches
  • Capacity: up to 16 lbs.
  • Output: Not specified

More features: TRU-Infrared cooking technology, easy to use, versatile, large capacity, has a drip tray

Say goodbye to hot cooking oil splatter, burned skin, and residual smell. Cook your turkey for the next Thanksgiving without any of these hassles with the Char-Broil Big Easy Oil-less Turkey Fryer. With no hot cooking oil to worry about managing or disposing of, this versatile appliance does it all! Inside its two 18-inch diameter tubes is a double-walled cylindrical assembly that eliminates cold spots and ensures evenly cooked food while not letting heat escape. The enclosed structure also helps keep moisture in, so your meat stays juicy and flavorful!

This oil-free Char-broil liquid propane turkey fryer is one of the best indoor turkey fryers in the market. It is the go-to choice if you have always desired to eat healthy foods that are not deep-fried in oil. This cooker will save you liters of oil which you would have used to deep fry your food in other types of turkey fryers.

Why are we impressed?

  • The most intriguing feature we like about the Char-Broil oil-less cooker is the fact that it doesn't require any oil at all. No messy clean-up either as there are no spills on the floor. There is no grease build-up inside the unit because there is nothing to collect. Also, since there is no oil involved, there won't be any odor left behind after using the product. The cooker also does more than just frying a turkey; you can roast chicken, beef, pork tenderloin, and many other types of meat.

What negatives must you be aware of?

  • One downside of the Char-Broil oil-free turkey fryer is that it takes longer to cook meals than its electric and propane counterparts. So, you need to wait long before your oil can heat up or your water can boil so you can start preparing your meal. Its cooking time is 8 to 10 minutes per pound. Another thing that could have made this cooker better is a bigger capacity. The Char-Broil oil-free cooker can only cook foods and birds up to a weight of 16 pounds.
RELATED: 5 Best Oil-less Turkey Fryers – Healthier Choice!

Things to Consider

Buying a turkey fryer might seem like a straightforward task. However, it is not a walk in the park. First, you must access whether you need the equipment. You should be knowing its advantages, uses, and so forth. If you know what you’re looking for, then it will be easier for you.

Advantages of Turkey Fryers

Turkey fryers come with several benefits. When you are frying that turkey using the equipment instead of other traditional methods such as pan-frying, there are some gains that you will accrue. They include the following:

Healthy meals

Oil-less fryers help reduce fat intake by eliminating the need to use oils. They also do away with messes caused by spilled liquids and eliminate odors created during cooking. Their oil counterparts also use less fat compared to pan-frying.

Convenient features

Most turkey fryers come with a digital timer, automatic or adjustable thermostat, frying thermometer to keep tabs on temperature levels, and so forth. These features make cooking easier than compared to pan-frying.

Cook faster

Turkey fryers have powerful burners that heat up quickly. As such, they allow cooks to prepare their dishes within short periods. In addition, they make sure that the food gets appropriately heated.

Easy cleaning

8 Best Turkey Fryers for a Thanksgiving Staple
Ovens and pans get dirty and greasy after cooking. In contrast, oil-less turkey fryers do not use oil and hence do not have greasy stains. This feature makes them easy to clean. A turkey fryer is therefore ideal for busy people who cannot spend hours cleaning pots and pans.

Important Features

When buying turkey fryer cooking equipment, there are some things to consider. You don’t just buy anything that comes along. Make sure that what you’re purchasing has features that suit your needs.

Material

The first thing you should consider when looking for the best countertop turkey fryers or outdoor fryers is what material was used to make them. A turkey fryer pot made of a strong alloy of aluminum and stainless steel will be more durable than one made of ductile and brittle materials. Do not only pay attention to the main pot’s material but also the whole fryer’s material. Everything, including the inner baskets and lid, should be firm and not prone to dents. The base stand should also be made of heavy-duty metal. It shouldn’t bend easily under pressure to avoid toppling and accidents. The Bass Pro Shops 30-Quart Propane Turkey Fryer above is one of the most stable and durable cookers you can choose if you want something that will last.

Size

Another factor to think about is size. When choosing a turkey fryer, ensure that it fits nicely inside your kitchen cabinet. This way, you won’t have to worry about moving it from place to place now and again. Some types of turkey fryers may require too much room. For example, large ones occupy lots of space and are perfect for outdoor use or large kitchens.

On the contrary, small-sized ones fit perfectly in smaller kitchens. If you have a small kitchen, we recommend the CreoleFeast TFK3001 Propane Turkey and Fish Fryer above, which occupies the least volume of 12.99 x 12.99 x 29.92 inches. Go for a voluminous cooker like the Char-Broil Big Easy Oil-less Liquid Propane Turkey Fryer covered in this write-up if you have much space in your kitchen.

Capacity

You also need to look beyond just the physical size. Check how many pounds of turkey can the fryer you want to buy handle. If you cook smaller birds and foods, then go for a smaller size. If you cook heavy turkeys, then you might want a larger size. A good quality turkey fryer must have enough capacity to cook several meals at once or larger birds. If you choose a smaller fryer, you will be forced to separate your bird or food into several parts and cook each separately. Separate cooking is a waste of time and energy. If you are looking for a fryer with a large capacity, we recommend the Bass Pro Shops 36-Quart All-In-One Fryer Kit above, which can handle a bird of up to 22 pounds of weight. The cooker can also cook multiple meals at the same time. For instance, you could be boiling something while steaming your vegetables at the same time.

Output

If you plan to use the turkey fryer often, you’ll be better off getting a model that produces high heat output. A cooker with a high output consumes less oil and cooks faster. However, keep in mind that higher temperatures mean increased risks of burns and fires. So, before making any purchase, check whether the manufacturer offers safety measures such as thermostats and the quality of material used. Also, you might want to consider the fuel used. The fryers are known to have higher outputs use propane. The best electric turkey fryers around can’t even beat the heat produced by these cookers. For this, you should try out the LoCo Cookers SureSpark Turkey Fryer covered above.

Accessories

8 Best Turkey Fryers for a Thanksgiving Staple
As you buy your turkey fryer, check to see the accessories you will get after purchasing it. You do not want to buy a fryer that comes with missing crucial components. Check out for accessories such as the meat thermometer, which helps you monitor the temperature. Check the maximum temperature the thermometer can measure and its length. You should also check for other components, such as inner frying and steaming baskets, that are available. Some manufactures sell the burner base part and the top aluminum parts separately. So be sure that your fryer contains all that. If you are looking for the best electric turkey deep fryers, make sure you check for accessories such as the size of the electric cord and so forth. If you are looking for a convenient turkey fryer with all the essential accessories, then the LoCo Cookers 36-Qt. Turkey Fryer above should be the right for you.

Design

The design of the turkey fryer plays an important role when buying one. It’s best if the unit looks attractive so that people would love having it around their home. Also, make sure that the product has been designed, keeping safety in mind. Look for features such as easy cleaning, low maintenance, non-slip surfaces, and so forth. In addition, avoid models that come with sharp edges and corners. These can cause injuries, especially to children who play near them. If you are looking for the best design, then the Char-Broil Big Easy Oil-less Liquid Propane Turkey Fryer is the best choice for you. The cooker is easy to clean, has no edges, and requires minimal maintenance.

Safety features

When choosing a turkey fryer, ensure that it includes some critical safety features. Safety features include alarms, timers, and smoke detectors, among others. Make sure that the alarm sounds whenever there is a problem. Alarms help prevent accidents from happening. They also alert users about issues like overheating. When purchasing a turkey fryer, always opt for those that offer safety features. The safest turkey fryer is the LoCo Cookers SureSpark Turkey Fryer covered above. This model has an electric ignition system, an intelligent temperature control system, a safety timer, and a stable stand.

FAQ

It will depend on what kind of food you are cooking. If you are frying a turkey, the first step should be pouring enough oil into the cooker. Light it up once you have done so and wait for the oil to heat up to the right temperature. The heating up might take close to 20 minutes, depending on your fryer’s output power and the amount of oil you have used. Once the proper temperature has been achieved, dip your turkey using the fryer basket. Set the timer and leave it to cook for 5 to 10 minutes per pound. Once it is ready, use your handles to lift your turkey. For steaming or boiling, start by adding some water into the main pot. Depending on your recipe, you can wait till the water boils or just insert the steaming rack right away. Once your food is ready, lift it using the safety handles.

It will depend on the type of turkey fryer you have bought. You can only use the one designed for indoor use inside your house. Some fryers are designed to be used for both outside and indoor cooking. However, those designed for outdoor use should not be used for indoor cooking. They have been designed to handle outdoor conditions and not the ones inside your house. Also, most of them have weak base stands. If they topple inside your home, it could be catastrophic and possibly result in a fire. So, inside your house, only use those turkey fryers designed for indoor and outdoor use or those specifically made for indoor use only.

Cleaning a turkey fryer is very simple. Start by making sure the burner is off. The next step should be disconnecting the cooker from its source of fuel. If it’s propane, disconnect the propane gas tank. If it uses electricity, then disconnect the part which contains electrical components. Next, remove all its constituent parts, including the lid. Then wash everything thoroughly under running tap water. Do not put your turkey fryer in a dishwasher if it is not dishwasher safe. After washing and rinsing your equipment, dry off everything before putting back together again. Ensure that you don’t forget any part while doing this process.

Our Verdict

The above eight turkey fryers that we have reviewed are currently the best in the market. The cookers have the best safety features and tons of other desirable characteristics. For our Editor’s Choice, we settled for the Bass Pro Shops 30-Quart Propane Turkey Fryer, and it gives you every quality you would be looking for in a turkey fryer. The 30-Quart cooker has a CSA-approved safety timer, a sturdy metal stand, adjustable safety brackets, and a large capacity to cook 18 pounds of food.

Our Premium Pick, the Bass Pro Shops 36-Quart All-In-One Fryer Kit, has the largest capacity to handle birds with a weight of up to 22 pounds. The fryer can cook two different meals at the same time due to its enormous volume. The cooker that offers you the best value for your money is the LoCo Cookers 36-Qt. Turkey Fryer. As one of the best turkey fryers in the market, this cooker has a powerful burner, large capacity, intelligent temperature control sensors, and many other valuable features.

References

1.
Thanksgiving with Alexander Hamilton: Stewed eels, 'promiscuous' seating
You might envision a celebration that would look like our image of the quintessential American Thanksgiving — family and friends gathered around a table laden with roast turkey and all the fixings. That certainly would fit with a quote widely attributed to Hamilton: “No citizen of the U.S. shall refrain from turkey on Thanksgiving Day.”
2.
Although a mighty delicious tradition, deep-frying a turkey on Thanksgiving can be risky. Every year deep-fryer fires are responsible for five deaths, 60 injuries, the destruction of 900 homes, and more than $15-million in property damage, according to the National Fire Protection Association.
Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *